Click here to learn
about this Sponsor:
Home  |  News  |  Articles  |  Polls  |  Forum

Keywords: Match:
The thinking behind the Wonka Public License
Steven Buytaert and Chris Gray (Dec. 14, 2001)

Recently ACUNIA released Wonka, their implementation of the Java language, under a BSD-style license. In this guest column, ACUNIA Chief Technology Officer Steven Buytaert and VM Architect Chris Gray explain the reasons behind the decision . . .

The Wonka license is located here.

Buytaert: ACUNIA's flagship product is the Open Telematics Framework (OTF).
The OTF is completely Java-based, and pre-supposes the existence of terminals -- dashboard computers, set-top boxes, next-generation cellphones, etc. -- having a certain level of Java capability. When we were developing the OTF, we quickly found that the kind of Java capability we had in mind was not readily available in the right form factor: existing implementations of Java were too big, too expensive, too limited, or simply not ready for prime time. This led us to develop Wonka for internal use, and by making Wonka available as Open Source our aim is quite simply to raise the general level of embedded Java. Wonka embodies our ideas of what consumer-device Java should look like, and acts as a reference: we show not only what can be done, but even how to do it.

Gray: For this strategy to work it was essential that the license not pose a barrier to using Wonka in embedded devices. Had we released Wonka under the GNU General Public License (GPL), we would immediately have run into problems, both with the way that embedded systems are generally built, and with the use of Java as a medium for delivering executable content. In the first place, most embedded devices use an RTOS which is statically linked with the application code to create a single binary module. Few if any RTOSes are distributed under a license which is compatible with the GPL, so there is no way that the resulting binary could be legally packaged and sold (or even given away). Secondly, a system such as ACUNIA's OTF makes considerable use of the dynamic loading features of Java: when a user signs up to use a service, the Java code needed to use that service is automatically "pushed" to her terminal. Is it legal to link proprietary code which has been "pushed" in this way into a GPL'd Java system? "Probably" is not the kind of answer you want to give to a bank, publisher, or car manufacturer. And lastly, there are some practical difficulties: normally a device such as a cellphone does not offer a way to reprogram its internal ROMs, but the language of the GPL seems to imply that this should be possible.

Buytaert: Some companies solve this problem by making the same software available under both the GPL (for free) and another license (for paying customers). Sometimes this is even cited as an advantage of the GPL: that you can issue something as Free Software and still charge companies money for using it. We decided against this approach because to us it seems like an abuse of the Open Source idea: it reduces the GPL to a kind of "free for evaluation and private use" license. That's not our idea of contributing to the Open Source community.

Gray: We could have gone with something like the LGPL or the GPL with an "exception" clause of some kind, but we felt we could achieve the same end result more simply by going for a BSD-style license. At first we included a clause (modeled on the Apache license) which required written permission from ACUNIA to use the name "Wonka" for a modified version, but later we realized that this was not necessary: ACUNIA can defend its trademarks without having to mention this explicitly in the license. And a technical incompatibility between this clause and the GPL would have made it impossible to combine our work with some GPL'd stuff to make a larger whole. Even though we don't think that GPL is the right model for embedded software, we wouldn't want to prevent Wonka from being used together with GPL-ware in research work, or in projects like the Simputer.

Buytaert: This issue reinforces our belief that in an open-source software license, simplicity is a virtue. Recently many companies have brought out software under complicated licenses which claim to provide all the benefits of Open Source without the alleged disadvantages such as "forking" of the project. Unfortunately the cure is often worse than the disease: the more licenses proliferate, and the more clauses in each license, the greater the chance that some clause of license "A" will clash with a clause of license "B", without either company having intended such a conflict. The Open Source community is also rightly suspicious of such licenses, and in more than one case the license has had to be rewritten to meet the legitimate concerns of the community. By basing the Wonka license on a tried-and-tested formula, we avoid the need to go through such a cycle and can be confident that the Wonka license meets the needs of embedded source developers and complies with the OSI's Open Source Definition.



Talk back! Do you have comments or questions on this story? talkback here



Related stories:

(Click here for further information)


FUEL Database on MontaVista Linux
Whether building a mobile handset, a car navigation system, a package tracking device, or a home entertainment console, developers need capable software systems, including an operating system, development tools, and supporting libraries, to gain maximum benefit from their hardware platform and to meet aggressive time-to-market goals.

Breaking New Ground: The Evolution of Linux Clustering
With a platform comprising a complete Linux distribution, enhanced for clustering, and tailored for HPC, Penguin Computing¿s Scyld Software provides the building blocks for organizations from enterprises to workgroups to deploy, manage, and maintain Linux clusters, regardless of their size.

Data Monitoring with NightStar LX
Unlike ordinary debuggers, NightStar LX doesn¿t leave you stranded in the dark. It¿s more than just a debugger, it¿s a whole suite of integrated diagnostic tools designed for time-critical Linux applications to reduce test time, increase productivity and lower costs. You can debug, monitor, analyze and tune with minimal intrusion, so you see real execution behavior. And that¿s positively illuminating.

Virtualizing Service Provider Networks with Vyatta
This paper highlights Vyatta's unique ability to virtualize networking functions using Vyatta's secure routing software in service provider environments.

High Availability Messaging Solution Using AXIGEN, Heartbeat and DRBD
This white paper discusses a high-availability messaging solution relying on the AXIGEN Mail Server, Heartbeat and DRBD. Solution architecture and implementation, as well as benefits of using AXIGEN for this setup are all presented in detail.

Understanding the Financial Benefits of Open Source
Will open source pay off? Open source is becoming standard within enterprises, often because of cost savings. Find out how much of a financial impact it can have on your organization. Get this methodology and calculator now, compliments of JBoss.

Embedded Hardware and OS Technology Empower PC-Based Platforms
The modern embedded computer is the jack of all trades appearing in many forms.

Data Management for Real-Time Distributed Systems
This paper provides an overview of the network-centric computing model, data distribution services, and distributed data management. It then describes how the SkyBoard integration and synchronization service, coupled with an implementation of the OMG¿s Data Distribution Service (DDS) standard, can be used to create an efficient data distribution, storage, and retrieval system.

7 Advantages of D2D Backup
For decades, tape has been the backup medium of choice. But, now, disk-to-disk (D2D) backup is gaining in favor. Learn why you should make the move in this whitepaper.

 


Got a HOT tip?   please tell us!
Free weekly newsletter
Enter your email...
Click here for a profile of each sponsor:
PLATINUM SPONSORS
GOLD SPONSORS
(Become a sponsor)

ADVERTISEMENT
(Advertise here)

Check out the latest Linux powered...

mobile phones!

other cool
gadgets



BREAKING NEWS

• Hacker-friendly karaoke PMP runs Linux
• Maemo gains KOffice port
• OLPC partners with Amazon, ITU
• "cJTAG" debuts
• First $100 laptop runs Linux
• First Linux on Everest
• Dell ships Ubuntu- and Atom-based netbook
• Smallest x86 board ever?
• MontaVista Vision gains focus
• "Olympics" phone runs Linux
• Android Challenge winners push location awareness
• Atmel-based industrial SBC runs Linux
• Atom squeezes onto Pico-ITX board
• Via frees Chrome graphics driver source
• Webinar dissects Linux multicore migration


Most popular stories -- past 90 days:
• Open source phone goes mass-market
• Updated! Linux Mobile Phones Showcase
• World's cheapest Linux-based laptop?
• Garmin Nav devices run Gnome Linux
• First Atom-based notebook runs Linux
• ARM9 board boots Debian in 0.69 seconds
• Open source camera records geotagged video to SATA HDD
• Linux-friendly Beagle fetches $150
• "PDA phone" runs Linux
• Intel offers $80 "Little Falls" Atom mobo
• Netflix Player runs Linux


DesktopLinux headlines:
• OSCON 2008 presentations, videos posted
• Debian distro named for little green man
• Google spins web browser
• Summit debuts for Linux end users
• "UbuntuLite" reviewed
• Linux in the SME
• Linux: not yet photo-friendly
• Linux to gain anti-virus software
• Linux gains backup utility
• Testing Lenny


Also visit our sister site:


Sign up for LinuxDevices.com's...

news feed

Home  |  News  |  Articles  |  Polls  |  Forum  |  About  |  Contact
 

Ziff Davis Enterprise Home | Contact Us | Advertise | Link to Us | Reprints | Magazine Subscriptions | Newsletters
Tech RSS Feeds | White Papers | ROI Calculators | Tech Podcasts | Tech Video | VARs | Channel News

Baseline | Careers | Channel Insider | CIO Insight | DesktopLinux | DeviceForge | DevSource | eSeminars |
eWEEK | Enterprise Network Security | LinuxDevices | Linux Watch | Microsoft Watch | Mid-market | Networking | PDF Zone |
Publish | Security IT Hub | Strategic Partner | Web Buyer's Guide | Windows for Devices

Developer Shed | Dev Shed | ASP Free | Dev Articles | Dev Hardware | SEO Chat | Tutorialized | Scripts |
Code Walkers | Web Hosters | Dev Mechanic | Dev Archives | igrep

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Except where otherwise specified, the contents of this site are copyright © 1999-2008 Ziff Davis Enterprise Holdings Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Ziff Davis Enterprise is prohibited. Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds. All other marks are the property of their respective owners.